The 19-year-old Canadian pilot Fernand L. Jolicoeur crashed in a Lancaster bomber near Waldenbuch/Germany on January 28, 1945. His descendants are still reeling from the loss of the young man. Where exactly did my great-uncle crash, and what happened back then – these are the questions that the great-nephew of the crash victim Jean-Pierre Gendreau-Hétu has been looking for an answer to these questions for many years. Via detours, the inquiry of the 55-year-old Canadian has now landed with the local historian team of Alt-Waldenbuch, who have undertaken meticulous research.
The crash scenario
The last double raid by Royal Airforce bombers on the Stuttgart area took place on Sunday, 28 January 1945 between 20:35 and 20:54 and in a second wave between 23:30 and 23:48. A total of about 800 bombers were used, of which 539 reached their target area. About 10,500 explosive and incendiary bombs were dropped. The total casualties were 119 dead, 78 wounded and 5,500 homeless. The weather was bad and the pilots had to fly long detours. There were numerous plane crashes in the process. This was also the case in the Waldenbuch state forest. It must have been dramatic scenes that took place at that time. About a kilometer from the town, in the Lindhalde forest area, the badly hit Lancaster bomber KB 770 NA-D of the Royal Airforce and its British and Canadian crew crashes into the forest with its engines on fire. Five of the seven occupants are recovered dead. Two crew members survive seriously injured.
Searching for the crash site
Unfortunately it was not possible to get usable aerial photos. Possibly the area around Waldenbuch was not militarily interesting enough, so that there are no pictures of the crash site, or the low resolution of the photos does not show anything.
The response to the plane crash in three local newspapers and on the Waldenbuch Facebook group in February 2021 was unexpectedly large. More than 30 eyewitnesses came forward – of which Mrs. Ursula Niebel from Waldenbuch was the oldest at 92..
Here are some important details of these people about the event:
Ursula Niebel from Waldenbuch, born 1929
“I was walking with my friends down a little path in the woods towards the crash site and I remember a dead pilot lying there. He was covered with the parachute. I lifted the parachute a little and looked into the face of a very young man. I didn’t go back to the wreckage of the plane.”
Hans Hartmann from Waldenbuch, born 1936
As a 9-year-old he was in the night in question together with his family in the vaulted cellar of the neighbor, because air raids were expected constantly. Therefore, we only heard the crash of the plane. It was a loud bang. The crash site is quite close, above our barn. My father and I walked there later. There were only fragments of the plane left, one engine and various parts. We took screws with us, which were very rare at that time. But unfortunately the screws didn’t fit, because they were in the English inch format.
Hermann Adam from Plieningen, born 1936
The plane flew from east to west, very low and slow. It was shot at from all sides. From the German flak, that has been seen. The flak was in Leinfelden and at the edge of the airport. He thought at the time that the plane would not get far. You could see that the plane was struggling. It was already shot. It flew exactly in the direction of Waldenbuch. But the engines were not burning yet.
Helmut Hanselmann from Steinenbronn, born 1930
We ran from Steinenbronn to Waldenbuch on Monday at noon to the place where the plane crashed. The wreckage was lying with its nose to the road in the direction of Weil im Schönbuch. There were soldiers everywhere. The track caused by the plane could be seen for many years.
Some of the contemporary witnesses report that the crash site was visited by many Waldenbuchers for years to come and that they took many parts lying around with them. It is reported that intact large plastic tanks were later used by farmers as manure barrels. Nothing is known about the salvage of the wreckage of the plane, which took place in the following days by the Wehrmacht. In the local newspapers the crash was probably hushed up for political reasons.
Further a not named Waldenbucher reports that he searched the crash site with a probe around the year 2000 and found something. He reports among other things that the middle part of the Lancaster must have burned, since there were clear traces by soil excavations. The tail section was probably still in order. One found still each quantity splinters. The machine must have lost buoyancy, dropped like a stone, hit the ground on its belly and not slid far. They also found plexiglass from the pilot’s cabin as well as the swivel head, presumably from the lower weapon stand. According to the deceased witness Ernst Kayser the wings must have been intact. They were pulled down the slope to the forest road in February 1945 and taken away.
Based on these reports and site visits together with contemporary witnesses in the Lindhalde area, the crash site was finally identified. With the support of helpers, who deal with airplane crashes as a hobby, individual parts were also found, which are assigned by specialists to a Lancaster. The exact coordinates of the crash site are deliberately not mentioned here, in order not to encourage probe tourism.
The dead of the Lancaster crew
Harry Leslie Kay 🇨🇦 (C/888) Pilot, Squadron Leader of the Royal Canadian Air Force, Canadian, 32 years old.
Son of Dr. Amos Frank Kay, M.D., and Carolyn Kay; Husband of Ruth Norma Kay, from Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, U.S.A.
As fate would have it, he was killed on his first mission as a flight commander. 32 years old.
Gerald Joseph Liney 🇨🇦 (J.40040), Bomb-Aimer (A/B), Flying Officer, Canadian, age unknown. Called up to the Air Force 1941.
Son of Isabella Liney, and John Liney, Toronto,
John Wilfred “Wilf” Blades 🇨🇦 (J.35935) Wireless Operator/Air Gunner (Wop/AG), Flying Officer, Canadian, Royal Canadian Air Force. 35 years old
Son of W. Blades, Charleswood, married to Christina Hawthorne, Ford William
Fernand Leo Jolicoeur 🇨🇦 (J.95345 / R204027) Mid upper gunner/Air Gunner (MU/AG), Flight Sergeant, Royal Canadian Air Force, Canadian, 20 years old.
Son of Arthur and Eugenie Jolicoeur, of Ottawa, Ontario, Canada. Great-uncle of Jean-Pierre Gendreau-Hétu.
Reginald William Gullick 🇬🇧 (1895420) flight engineer (F/E), Sergeant, British, Royal Air Force Volunteer Reserve, 31 years old.
Son von Willam Gullick, and Ellen Gullick, aus Newport, Monmouthshire/Wales.
Members of the German Air Force and local police were quickly on the scene at the time, according to British Air Ministry records. The area was cordoned off. After the crash, the dead pilots were first temporarily buried in a communal grave in Waldenbuch until 1947, when they were buried in the Durnbach War Cemetery near Lake Tegernsee they found their final resting place.
The two survivors
The crew of an Avro Lancaster consisted of seven men. These were in detail the pilot, the navigator, the bombardier, the flight engineer, the radio operator, the cockpit gunner and the tail gunner.
Only the radio operator (Nav) R. L. Stapleford 🇨🇦, who was pulled out of the air stream, and the tail gunner (Rear A/G) E.F. Ossington survived the crash seriously injured. Both were treated in an Esslingen hospital. Stapleford later in 1945 gave the circumstances of the crash on record in Britain. According to him, five of the plane’s crew were killed. Also, he would have seen Joliceur’s jacket and ring.
Ossington returned to Canada and died in 1978 at the age of 60. Rita Ossington, daughter-in-law married to Ted’s middle son Bryn remembers Ted: . “Like so many he was reminded every day of his experience by the shrapnel in his legs and heal, plus the memories he did not share. There were only a few stories he shared about how he was medically discharged from the army because he was hurt and sent home and was invited to enlist in the Airforce. He was actually taking a buddy to enlist but he had flat feet or something. He didn’t qualify. The enlistment officer looked at Ted and said ” you should enlist.” When told about being medically discharged from the army the guy supposedly said “you don’t need good legs to be a rear gunner.”
Still many open questions
For years, Jean-Pierre Gendreau-Hétu has been particularly concerned with the fate of his dead great-uncle Fernand Leo Jolicoeur and has discovered inconsistencies that still leave him in doubt as to whether his great-uncle is actually buried in the common grave in Durnbach. He describes his concerns as follows:
Research in both the local and the Commonwealth registers reveals a gap in the body counts. Waldenbuch death register recorded the temporary burial of four bodies. The 1947 investigation report of an Allied commission also confirms the same number of bodies. However, five bodies were buried in Dürnbach!
The exhumation of the human remains in Waldenbuch and their transfer in 1948 to the central Durnbach War Cemetery, where finally all war victims of the Commonwealth found their final resting place, Here, however, according to the inscription of the common grave suddenly five bodies were buried (See photo above). Where did the fifth body come from?
There seems to be no record of this action, and one has to wonder how German witnesses counted four bodies in 1945 and Commonwealth authorities counted five in 1948? It is impossible to doubt that the four bodies Waldenbuchers buried in 1945 belonged to the crew of Lancaster KB770. Therefore, only individual DNA analysis would provide clarity, although not commonly done by war victims in the Allied armies, once a body is securely in place, even in a collective grave. Jean-Pierre Gendreau-Hétu’s family has already profiled their dead relative’s DNA, should the Commonwealth War Graves Commission one day set out to solve this World War II mystery.
“I just don’t like the idea of going into a common grave,” he explains, “and not being sure that the body that’s in there is the body of my great-uncle.”
Wolfgang Härtel, July 2021
Claudia Barner in Kreiszeitung Böblinger Bote of February 19th, 2021, page 15
Robert Bostelaar in Ottawa Citizen of July 6th, 2014, Local News
Commonwealth War Grave Commission
Heinz Bardua, Stuttgart im Luftkrieg 1939-1945, Klett-Cotta, 1985
The Wartime Memories Project Website
Durnbach War Cemetery
Jean-Pierre Gendreau-Hétu (for information and french translation of the page)
Jörg Mezger (for information on crash site and assignment of finds)
Roland Watzl (data procurement)
Mark Skyrme (found objects)
Bernhardt Menzel (found objects)
François Therrien (for various information)
Hugo Holzapfel (witnesses references)
Regina Steck (Cemetery book Waldenbuch)
William Butler, Command Historian, HQ U.S. European Command (Aerial photos)
Kai Lutz (photos)
Leon Kolb (photos)
Udo Rauch (info City Archives Tübingen)
Peter Fritz (found objects)
Günther Schwarz (plans and info about the Lindhalde)
Michael R. Deusch (photos help)
Monika Sanchez (paperwork)
Albrecht Leuthner (editing the report)
Memorial service for Fernand Leo Jolicoeur on August 16, 2021.
Finally, the research work on this plane crash had been completed with the help of many people. Six members of the French-Canadian family of Jean-Pierre Gendreau-Hétu came to Waldenbuch to visit the crash site. It was the great-uncle, Fernand L. Jolicoeur, who died in the Waldenbuch forest at the age of 19, together with four of his comrades. The small ceremony took place in a dignified setting at the crash site in the forest. Present were Mayor of Waldenbuch, Michael Lutz, forest district leader Daniel Berner as well as press representatives of the local Filder-Zeitung, Kreiszeitung Böblinger Bote and the US Army newspaper The Stuttgart Citizen. For the reports please click on the newspaper logos.
Here the English translation of the Filder-Zeitung newspaper article.